Loudoun Republicans Tell MWAA - No PLA and No Money for Dulles Rail Unless...

  
    This is a giant step toward protecting Loudoun and all of Virginia  from the power of  The Metropolitan Washington Airport Authority (MWAA). They are the un-elected, un-accountable and in many people's opinion an out -of-control body that is calling the shots on this proposed Phase 2 rail scheme. They (MWAA) are demanding hundreds of $millions in Union perks be added to the project and asking the State of Virginia to fork over hundreds of $millions to the rail project, while the MWAA Board is refusing to submit to audits or even FOIA requests. Their audacity is off the chart.
    The majority of the MWAA Board represent interests outside Virginia. Here is what the Loudoun Republican Committee has to say about that.

   On Monday night, November 28th,  2011 at the Loudoun County Republican Committee meeting in Leesburg, the LCRC voted unanimously to adopt a  Resolution with certain amendments made at the meeting. 

   The Resolution mirrors legislation (H.B. No. 2) pre-filed by Delegate Bob Marshall with the General Assembly, and was supported by Marshall and Senator-elect Dick Black.  Bob Marshall helped guide the discussion at the LCRC meeting.  Speaking at the meeting, in favor of the resolution were Delegate Joe May, Chairman of the Loudoun Board of Supervisors Scott York, Supervisor Eugene Delgaudio and several people from the Committee.  May's support was very important given his position as Chairman of the Appropriations - Transportation Subcommittee.
   The unanimous consensus among those voting at the meeting fuels hopes that other representatives, some of them in attendance at the meeting, are ready to take the lead on these difficult issues.


    State Senator-elect Richard Black has indicated he will post a companion bill in the senate, possibly as earlier as this week. Black commented that he is determined to "not let these interests get a foot in the door and begin to erode Virginia's Right-To-Work laws."
Black summed up his position by adding "this is not about saying yes or no to the rail project, it is about making sure that Virginia is not sending millions of taxpayers’ dollars to an unelected body (MWAA) that has closed meetings, will not submit to open audits, and has repeatedly ignored Government Accountability Office notices to improve its practices."


    A look at the LCRC resolution shows three primary concerns. First were addressed, it takes a position against PLAs and union driven rules for Dulles Rail Phase 2; second, it proposes that before any Virginia State funding goes to Dulles Rail, that MWAA subject itself to Virginia FOIA laws; and third, it seeks accountability through a state audit if state funding goes to the MWAA project.  The Resolution asks the Loudoun Board of Supervisors and the Loudoun Delegation to support these principles in legislation, not just state or federal executive assurances.

David LaRock

 
H.B. No. 2:  http://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?121+ful+HB2

LCRC resolution:  http://loudoungop.com/about/resolution.php?id=1563


PASSED November 28, 2011

Resolution to Oppose Project Labor Agreement or Union-Driven Rules for Dulles Rail

WHEREAS, Loudoun County has entered into an agreement with the Metropolitan Washington Airport Authority ("MWAA") to construct Rail to Dulles International Airport and 3 miles into Loudoun County; and

WHEREAS, the agreement with MWAA has not been finalized; and

WHEREAS, MWAA intends to mandate a Project Labor Agreement ("PLA") or union driven rules as part of the construction of Phase II of Dulles Rail; and

WHEREAS, such mandate would require the use of union workers and a wage which will effectively preclude most Virginia contractors and businesses from participation in Phase II construction, with most of Virginia contractors ineligible to compete; and

WHEREAS, such provisions mandating union workers undermine the Commonwealth of Virginia's Right to Work Laws, and

WHEREAS, such mandate would require 1.5 wages for hours beyond a 40 hour work week, rigid job classifications, work rules and wage rates (which are union driven) which will significantly increase the construction costs of Dulles Rail Phase II; and

WHEREAS, most Virginia contractors operate under an "open shop" arrangement without union driven mandates; and

WHEREAS, MWAA has very restrictive practices for open meetings, and freedom of Information access by the public which are inconsistent with Virginia law, and

WHEREAS no audit oversight of MWAA’s METRO extension construction project to Tyson's Corner, Dulles Airport and beyond was included for any agency of the Commonwealth when Governor Tim Kaine unilaterally relinquished control of the Dulles Toll Road to MWAA without General Assembly approval,

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Loudoun County Republican Committee call upon the Loudoun Board of Supervisors and the members of Loudoun's General Assembly delegation to oppose mandatory PLA provisions or union-driven rules in the final agreement with MWAA for the construction of Phase II of Dulles Rail, the lack of transparency and audit oversight by the Commonwealth; and that if Phase II construction proceeds that it not proceed under present conditions without these concerns being addressed by legislation, and not mere state or federal executive assurances, and be it further

RESOLVED, that the chairman of the Loudoun County Republican Committee shall cause copies of this resolution to be disseminated to the members of the Board of Supervisors and to the media.

Adopted this 28th day of November 2011

Mark Sell
Chairman
Loudoun County Republican Committee

Survey on Proposed Rail to Loudoun

click here  Take the RAIL SURVEY 

Should Loudoun spend up to $1Billion on Dulles Rail,

or OPT OUT and pay nothing?

 

Dulles Rail Slideshow

The Rail to Dulles Scheme is for Dummies.

I know it’s not nice to call people dummies, but the Dulles Rail promotion team (MWAA) must be thinking that is what they are dealing with. The good news is, we in Loudoun County still have time to prove these folks wrong.

This Dulles Rail 101 overview is simple because you don’t need to know all the details of a scam to know you are the about to become the victim.

 The train from Washington to Reston is now under construction. It’s in the news because it is behind schedule and way over budget. Rail promoters, the visionaries behind this idea, would also like to have a train come out to the airport and then keep going right on into Loudoun County. Sounds cool, right? At least until you get to the “Who pays for it” part.

To make big trains a reality, you need big money. Federal and State governments usually have lots more of our money to give back to us than they have right now. Absent that as a funding source, these Rail visionaries have put their imaginations to work, and guess who they are asking to finance this vision/dream.

Well, of course, the people who use the rail and the developers and businesses who benefit  will pay, right? Wrong.

The idea on the table now is a real piece of work. It says, let’s make the hard working commuters who use the Dulles Toll Road pay lots more in tolls.  I guess this is because these people still have jobs and that means they have extra money to subsidize the people who prefer riding trains. Okie dokie?

These Dulles Rail promoters apparently also heard that Loudoun and Fairfax Counties have lots of money, so they extended the invitation to them to ante up a few hundred million for construction. And just to sweeten the deal they are going to let us Loudoun/Fairfax people help pay tens of millions each year to cover the losses incurred because maintenance far exceeds income.  Are you liking the idea of big trains a little less right now?

This Rail promotional pitch is like a scene out of the “Music  Man” where the guy is telling us our community will never be complete if we don’t hurry up and buy into this big, expensive project. But reality will prevail if Rail to Loudoun goes through as it has played out many times where big government has tried to force rail where demand wouldn’t support it. It becomes a “black hole for money.”

Fairfax is seeing this reality right now because at the end of the day the savvy developers outsmart our elected people.  This excerpt from the Washington Times foretells where Loudoun is heading.

Although the Dulles Rail Full Funding Agreement, which the county signed on March 10, 2009, does not contain the actual words "cost overruns," county spokeswoman Merni Fitzgerald pointed out that "the funding agreement is based on the total cost of the project no matter what the cost is; therefore, [Fairfax County] pays 16.1 percent of the total project cost."

The county will use their property taxes to fund its 16.1 percent share of Dulles Rail's still-spiraling costs, including an estimated $400 million more for Phase II, while they are simultaneously forced to pay tolls projected to reach as high as $17, according MWAA's own July 11 report.

…while contributions by the federal government and wealthy Tysons landowners remain capped. Fairfax taxpayers were originally told that the entire 23-mile Metrorail extension would cost $3.6 billion -- or half of its current price tag. That they're now on the hook for most, if not all, of any future cost overruns racked up by the same contractor that ran up the tab for Boston's "Big Dig".

The other movie this situation brings to mind is “Dumb and Dumber.” If Loudoun County is so dumb that it watches Fairfax get railroaded and then jumps up and says “me next”, I believe we will be proving that in the Who is Dumber, contest, Loudoun will be the undisputable winner.

Time to "Get Smart" With Transportation

Smart Decisions

 Will Make Traffic Better!

If you want to relieve the worst traffic in the nation during tough economic times, you had better be smart about it.

As you may know, Loudoun and Fairfax Counties are wheeling and dealing on the proposed Phase 2 extension to Dulles Airport, “and beyond” as Buzz Light Year says.

What many people are learning is that there is a long list of serious concerns about this project. The biggest is undoubtedly the humungous cost to build and maintain, and the second is that it will make traffic much worse.

So why are our elected leaders even considering it? Good question.

If you care to know nothing else here are a few bullet points to consider.

·         Studies on this specific project admit rail will not relieve traffic congestion.

·         The current funding plan has Dulles Toll Road (DTR) users as the “Cash Cow” for the project,  that will make DTR tolls soar.

·         Common sense and various studies conclude higher tolls will push a huge percent of current DTR users back onto other roads, which will increase traffic congestion.

·         Just to make the integrity of this Phase 2 Project crystal clear, its planners insist on jacking up the costs by hundreds of millions of dollars as a perk to unions. And by-the-way, this arrangement will exclude 96% of Virginia contractors from working on the project. That sweet deal for unions, is called a Planned Labor Agreement, (PLA).

There are far better ways to improve traffic that cost far less than rail and are considerably more efficient. So next time you're parked in traffic, give a little thought to the idea that there are ways out of this mess, IF, our elected leaders will be smart about how they spend our money.

David LaRock

Calling on Loudoun Board of Supervisors to Establish an Oversight Committee

My friend Rob Whitfield, who probably knows more about Dulles Reil than any 10 other experts, has put together a resolution that captures many of the worst aspects of the Rail project. Hopefully the taxpayers and toll payers of Loudoun will start to see this project for the money BLACK HOLE it will be if they don't agree with the LoudounOptOut idea.

Resolution Calling on Loudoun Board of Supervisors to Establish an Oversight

Committee to Consider Dulles Rail Phase 2 Funding Issues

WHEREAS, the 11.5 mile extension of the Metrorail system from Reston to Dulles International Airport (Dulles) and into Loudoun County, with stops at Route 606 and Ryan Road, known as Dulles Rail Phase 2, has been planned for many years and  Loudoun County’s Master Transportation and Comprehensive Land Use Plans include provisions for Transit Oriented Development near the proposed stations; and

WHEREAS, despite years of planning and engineering design, the economic and financial feasibility for Dulles Rail Phase 2 has never been demonstrated by any entity, including the Federal Transit Administration, which rejected federal funding in 2002 due to lack of projected rail ridership demand in the Phase 2 service area; and

WHEREAS, the Phase 2 capital cost was estimated at $2.5 billion in 2007 when Loudoun County committed to a capital cost funding plan which would require the County to pay 4.8% of project capital costs and 4.8% of cost overruns on both Phase 1 and Phase 2; and further, the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority (MWAA) which assumed responsibility for building Dulles Rail in 2006, announced in September 2010 that estimated Phase 2 costs had increased to $3.8 billion, a figure reduced to approximately $3.2 billion in Summer 2011 following various design changes; and

WHEREAS, the two stations and three mile rail extension beyond Dulles will require an estimated $300 million ($400 million if financed by bonds)  in Loudoun County funds for its capital cost share to be provided by an estimated annual $60 million increase in Business, Professional and Occupancy License (BPOL) taxes in the period 2013 to 2018; and Loudoun County’s share of total long term operating costs and deficits are projected to be $30 million annually increasing over time over $1 Billion; and

WHEREAS, reliable estimates of the projected operating revenues and expenses of this Rail project have not yet been provided by the Washington Metro Area Transit Authority, and the magnitude of long term operating fund subsidies required of Loudoun County under the WMATA compact have not been disclosed, but it is known that these funding demands will compete with other County expenses and projects, notably Schools; and

WHEREAS, due to the lack of federal and state funding for the Dulles Rail Phase 2 project, MWAA has relied on Dulles Toll Road tolls as a source of 75% of capital costs which will cause DTR tolls to rise to levels above $10 each way and result in adverse economic impacts for commuters, residents and businesses in Loudoun County, and

WHEREAS, given that no federal or state funding or credit enhancement has been provided to the Phase 2 project to date, the likely overall cost of capital for Phase 2 will be in the 7% to 8% range versus the 6% average cost of capital experienced so far in Phase 1; further, these financing costs are far higher than experienced elsewhere in Virginia for new transportation projects; moreover, due to current bond market conditions,  financial rating agencies are averse to high risk projects which has forced MWAA to delay further financing of the Dulles Rail project until 2012, reflecting growing concern as to the viability of this means of financing for the bulk of the costs; and

WHEREAS,  a 2002 study of the rail ridership potential to Loudoun County did not demonstrate support for construction or operation of rail transit locally in that only 5% of overall local travel demand is expected to be rail based when built; and

WHEREAS, for Dulles Rail Phase II, MWAA intends to mandate the use of union workers and wage provisions which will effectively preclude most Virginia contractors and businesses from participation in Phase II construction, with 96% of Virginia contractors ineligible to compete; and

WHEREAS, MWAA and Loudoun County have agreed that Loudoun County may opt out of Phase II and owe nothing for Phase I costs if the opt out is made within 90 days of 100% preliminary engineering completion, anticipated in early 2012; and

WHEREAS legitimate concerns exist about the rail ridership demand, feasibility, excessive capital and operating costs, viability and wisdom of this project, which will likely result in enormous increases to overall Loudoun County taxpayer and commuter costs and adverse consequences to political candidates in the future who failed to act to prevent excessive costs and government  waste

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the creation of an independent , non-partisan Oversight Committee to study the costs/benefits and feasibility of the Dulles Rail Phase 2 project; and consider the net effects of the project on future land use development, environmental impacts, future commuting patterns and current and future travel demands; so that proper study and analysis is completed in time to provide recommendations to the County Board prior to the Spring 2012 deadline for County rail funding decisions; and be it further

RESOLVED, that the people of Loudoun County call upon the Loudoun Board of Supervisors to establish an independent and non-partisan Oversight Committee on or before December 15, 2011 to further study these issues with the goal of the Committee providing guidance to the new Board of Supervisors prior to finalizing its agreement for funding Phase II of the Dulles Rail project.

If you would like a PDF of this or a copy of the Power Point, just leave a comment and ask.

Delgaudio Opposes Taxpayer Funding of Dulles Rail

Eugene Delgaudio at Sterlingfest 2011

Eugene Delgaudio, a Republican Serving the area of Sterling for 12 years, is hoping to serve his community for another four. Based on his answers to questions posed to the three candidate in the Sterling district, on the costs of the Rail extension to Dulles,  Delgaudio said he hopes to privatize public transit so  residents can get it “cheaply, efficiently and quickly.” When it comes to Dulles Rail, he continues to oppose it.

Delgaudio also said, “As far as Metro is concerned, I think Metro is similarly a waste of money. If my focus is to go after waste and abuse and to be defending efficiency and government, I think that the whole topic of Dulles Rail is a boondoggle in the sense that look at the return,” Delgaudio said. “They are just told to pay for services they don’t get because they’re driving a car.”

Eugene Delgaudio has a very unique ability to spot a scam by looking past the carrot on the stick to see what is really going on. Even more unique is his willingness to represent his people’s best interests regardless of whether it is popular or not. His position on Rail to Dulles reflects this.

While many candidates and voters think a choo-choo train to the airport would be great, Eugene Delgaudio seems to realize this project isn’t a freebee.  There is an abundance of information showing that this project would have little or no benefit to businesses and it would cause a huge spike up in Dulles Toll Road tolls which would then force many commuters back onto roads ...and that spells MORE traffic.

County property taxes and business would likely shoot up to pay for Rail.  And by the way, tucked away in this Rail project is a $300 million union payoff called a Planned Labor Agreement (PLA). The information is there, all you need to do is go online to look at the Market and Fiscal Impact Analysis of the Phase 2 Metrorail Extension to Loudoun County Loudoun County | May 26, 2011  

Comments from the two other candidates  focused only on the promised benefits, not the costs. 

“ (Ali) Shahriari also wants Dulles Rail to extend as far as possible...”  

That’s a great idea but “Hello” Ali, where is the money coming from, have you heard that the Federal Government wants the local people to be the cash – cow for this.

Al Nevarez says,

 “Dulles Rail is our future. I think that we need to make sure it gets out here as soon as possible and it’s implemented in its full state,”

 Al appears to be clueless and has apparently bought the Rail scam hook line and sinker. He ought to wake up and realize that one of the big “economic opportunities” Rail brings is for the opportunity for criminals to commute from the cities out to the suburbs as they do on other rail lines.

My best guess is that Delgaudio "gets it" because he has the depth and experience. He has spotted this scheme as an ineffective, expensive “boondoggle” that will hurt, not improve the region.  

Hopefully Delgaudio will be re-elected and then help convince other Board members that extending Rail to Dulles and into Loudoun is a hugely expensive, utterly unnecessary burden to put on the backs of taxpayers. 

 David LaRock